“The critical slab that Görg spotted in the Berlin
Museum contains three
name-rings. Unfortunately, some of the name-ring on
the right has been
chipped off. It is only a little more than half
there. And of course it is the one
that is said to contain the name “Israel.” This
hacking may have happened
in modern times when the piece was looted. The slab
appears to have been
part of the pedestal of a statue”.
Hershel Shanks
When Did Ancient Israel Begin? - The BAS Library
When Did Ancient Israel Begin?
New hieroglyphic inscription may date Israel’s
ethnogenesis 200 years earlier than you thought
Longtime BAR readers are familiar
with the Merneptah Stele, now in the Egyptian Museum in Cairo, which is
generally recognized as containing the oldest extrabiblical reference to
Israel. …. The hieroglyphic inscription can be dated quite precisely to
somewhere between 1210 and 1205 B.C.E.
Damien Mackey’s comment: I would suggest a date about half a millennium
later than that:
‘Israel Stele’ unplaceable until Pharaoh Merenptah locked in
(4)
‘Israel Stele’ unplaceable until Pharaoh Merenptah locked in
Hershel Shanks continues:
But is it the oldest?
Egyptologists are now twittering about whether
there is another hieroglyphic inscription, centuries earlier than the Merneptah
Stele, that mentions Israel.
If so, this may have significant implications for
the early history of Israel, they say, suggesting that the Bible is more
reliable than some doubting scholars have been willing to admit.
The new candidate was spotted in the storerooms of
the Egyptian Museum of Berlin by University of Munich Hebrew Bible scholar and
Egyptologist Manfred Görg on a gray granite slab 18 inches high and 15.5 inches
wide. The slab was acquired by the museum in 1913 from the famous founder of
the German Archaeological Institute in Cairo, Ludwig Borchardt, who had
acquired it from an antiquities dealer.
It was common for Egyptian pharaohs to adorn their
tombs and temples with scenes and inscriptions boasting of their conquests.
Merneptah, for example, boasts that “Israel is laid waste; its seed is not,”
clearly a gross exaggeration. It was also common for pharaohs to put the names
of places they conquered in rows of what scholars call name-rings. Each
name-ring consists of a small image of a prisoner presenting a place conquered;
below the neck of the prisoner an oval cartouche-like ring contains the name of
the conquered place in hieroglyphic.
The critical slab that Görg spotted in the Berlin
Museum contains three name-rings. Unfortunately, some of the name-ring on the
right has been chipped off.
It is only a little more than half there. And of
course it is the one that is said to contain the name “Israel.” This hacking
may have happened in modern times when the piece was looted. The slab appears
to have been part of the pedestal of a statue.
Sometimes the face or hat of the prisoner can help
scholars identify a doubtful conquered place within a name-ring. For example,
another slab made of the same gray granite that appears to have come from the
pedestal of the same statue contains a name-ring of a prisoner who is clearly a
Nubian—and the name in the name-ring, unsurprisingly, also appears to be
Nubian. The three prisoners on the slab that may contain the name Israel are
all clearly West Semites—recognizable by their typical shoulder-length hair,
headbands and pointed beards—a significant clue to the identification of the
name as Israel.
Although the hieroglyphs in the ring on the right
are only partially preserved, they can be reconstructed with some confidence.
The problem arises because, if this is Israel, it is spelled slightly
differently from the spelling of Israel in the Merneptah Stele.
In Hebrew, the same letter represents
the sound “s” and “sh.” In hieroglyphic the two sounds are represented by
different signs. The Merneptah Stele uses a hieroglyphic “s” in the name
Israel; the Berlin Museum slab uses a “sh” hieroglyph. …. On this basis
and others, James Hoffmeier, an Egyptologist from Trinity Evangelical Divinity
School, maintains that the name cannot reasonably be read as Israel.
Israeli paleographer Shmuel Ahituv agrees with
Hoffmeier. ….
Disagreeing with them, however, are not only Görg,
but also Peter van der Veen of the University of Mainz and Christoffer Theis of
the University of Heidelberg. All three have jointly written a scholarly
defense of the “Israel” reading. …. They point out that there is no known
West Semitic toponym, other than Israel, that these hieroglyphs could be
identified with. “What other name in the same general region would be so
strikingly reminiscent as that of Biblical Israel?” they ask rhetorically.
Moreover, many toponyms are spelled in more than one way in hieroglyphic
inscriptions. Indeed, the spelling can be a key to dating the inscription, as
we shall see.
The German scholars also have another string to
their bow: the other two name-rings on this slab of granite. One of the other
names is Ashkelon, in southern Israel. The third name appears to be Canaan,
although there is some question as to whether it refers generally to the land
of Canaan or more specifically to the city of Gaza. As the German scholars
contend, “The geographical proximity of [the proposed name Israel] to Ashkelon
and Canaan makes the identification with Israel likely.”
Strengthening this argument is the text of the
Merneptah Stele.
In the verses adjacent to the reference to Israel
are Canaan and Ashkelon! The proximity of the same names in the two
inscriptions, in the words of the three German scholars cited above,
“seems to suggest that both texts are related in some way,” thus buttressing
the reading “Israel.”
The next question is how to date the hieroglyphs on
the slab that may contain the name Israel. There is nothing in the slab itself
that provides any hint. So the Egyptologists look to paleography and
orthography, that is, the form of the hieroglyphic signs and the spelling of
the names. The way the hieroglyphs are written and the spelling of the names
changed over time, and that provides a key to the date of the inscription.
A leading Israeli Egyptologist, Raphael Giveon, has
dated the inscription to about 1400 B.C.E (during the reign of Amenhotep III),
200 years earlier than the Merneptah inscription.
Damien Mackey’s comment: Once again, I would suggest dates about half a
millennium later than these dates.
I have identified Amenhotep III with the C9th BC
biblical Syrian king, Ben-Hadad I:
There has to be more empire to Ben-Hadad I and his rulership
(4)
There has to be more empire to Ben-Hadad I and his rulership
Hershel Shanks continues:
The three German scholars cited above suggest
Ramesses II as another possibility, even though they prefer a date nearer 1400
B.C.E. This famous pharaoh, often associated with the Israelite enslavement in
Egypt, reigned for much of the 13th century (1279–1213 B.C.E.).
Most scholars accept the ethnogenesis of Israel … in
about 1200 B.C.E., the end of the Late Bronze Age or the beginning of the Iron
Age, archaeologically speaking. But reading the name Israel in this slab in the
Berlin Museum raises the question of whether Biblical Israel had its
ethnogenesis centuries earlier.
….
Nothing conclusive here, but much food for thought.

For more, see:
(with Christoffer Theis and Manfred Görg), Israel in Canaan (long)
before Merenptah? A Fresh Look at Berlin Statue Pedestal Relief 21687, JAEI 2:4
(2010), 1-11

No comments:
Post a Comment